Do programmers hate their jobs?

Having been searching for a new job lately, I've read a number of advices to job seekers and hiring managers. Perhaps, they're just parroting each other, but here are some quotes that sound surprisingly similar:

Passion. We look for evidence that the applicant is passionate about computers and really loves programming. Typical evidence of this: <...>

  • Extra-curricular activities. People who love programming often work on their own programming projects (or contribute to an open-source project) in their spare time.

Joel Spolsky, Sorting Resumes blog post

When I'm hiring, I'm attracted to open source projects for one reason above all others: it shows a degree of passion. It shows that you're really not just a "clock out and forget about computing until you come in the next day" kind of guy.

Jon Skeet, 2nd comment to a "Coding horror" blog entry

3. Although this is not a universal truth, open source developers are very passionate about what they do. They have to be, otherwise why would they do it? If you hire an open source developer that has a passion for their work on open source projects, it might very well spill over into the work they do for you. Now I understand that many developers are passionate about their work (I've read Microserfs ;-) ), but passion in the open source community runs a bit hotter than it does in the non-open source communities.

Jack Wallen, "Five reasons why your company should hire open source developers" article

The problem with open source contributions is that they don’t necessarily tell a recruiter what they need to know about you. They indicate passion and enthusiasm for programming, which is a plus, but they don’t necessarily indicate competence <...>

James McKay, "Some thoughts on the role of open source experience in recruitment" blog post

And if that's not enough, keep in mind that most programmers who work on open source projects do so because they love writing software and they're passionate about their work.

Brian W. Fitzpatrick, The Virtual Referral: Mitigating Risk by Hiring Open Source Developers article

If we advance a bit, the general idea is that you should participate in an open-source development, or you're not a real man! You're not passionate! You... may not even love programming at all, you, corporate clerk?

The concept reminded me of something similar. Isn't it like suggesting that every worthy man must have a mistress as well as a wife? Which is, of course, bogus, even if one stops at the wife part, but a programmer is supposed to cheat on their job.

So why these seasoned managers, who just have to be mostly serious in their hiring-related statements, claim something that looks completely out of touch? I can't question their proficiency and experience, hence the conclusion is simple.

Most programming jobs suck.

With all the stuff heard and adopted--that programmers are lucky to have a profession that is, at the same time, fun--the reality doesn't seem to look as a fairy tale. Programming jobs suck hard and often, and you're more likely to demonstrate passion by participating in side-projects, than by doing well at work.

My job is not of the best, but I still want to go there each morning, and my eyes still burn, even after two years of marriage... Of course, sometimes we had difficulties, but we've eventually made up with each other. And the occasional urge to do something different is well satisfied by flirting with small projects, like writing this website, or participating in GSoC.

***

Do not take this post too seriously. Its argumentation is superficial and I admit I should have read, for example, that Spolsky's book ("Smart and Get Things Done") for extended explanations. I just told about an interesting observation that may be wrong. Or may not. So, do most programmers hate their jobs?

Back to A Foo walks into a Bar...


Comments
https://me.yahoo.com/prob_not_sol on 22 February 2010 commented:

I haven't hated my last few programming jobs at all. And I also have virtually no respect for Spolsky and his obvious opinions. The guy is a businessman; you cannot trust these people to give their real opinions, or even opinions of any particular use (in general) as they are often trying to sell something (his book, his website, etc).

I don't feel like ranting about my opinions on open source projects and developers. I think it's enough to say you should search for passionate people (but this is as obvious as the nose on my face). The ways to find them differ, but it's easy enough to spot. I don't think Open Source Commitments are the only way, or even a good way.

I think the hiring of smart people is made to seem more difficult. It's not that hard really; you just have interesting work, and pay well, with a good location, and they will come to you. People like to do interesting things that they enjoy for money; this is a fact of life. It applies to all fields, not just programming.

So lets stop listening to the people who run recruitment websites and have personal interests in such things on such matters, and engage our own brains in some logical and trivial thought on the matter.

Pavel Shved on 23 February 2010 commented:

The logic of the post may be narrowed to "If Spolsky's advice is useful, then most programmer jobs suck". If we prove that the latter is false, then we can judge whether the former is true. :-)

By the way, some quotes I posted (including the Spolsky's one) outlines the other ways of finding passionate people. Sometimes in such articles the open source is not mentioned at all. I just was bothered with the tendention.

Your way of hiring smart people seems good. But the thing is that, if you pay well, and are located in a nice place, then lots of people, who can't program but just want to get money, will apply for your job. You have to choose, and the way you make choice is all these hiring posts are about.

And the last thing. To locate and extract the gist of a subject one should have some bit of wisdom. When you read it, it looks trivial, but nontrivial is to spot it.

To make comments you should log in with OpenID (learn more).
Log in and make a comment >>